
Why Didn’t My Shrooms Work? 7 Reasons and What to Do Next
By Lily Pelenis / June 16, 2025 / 11 min read
If your shrooms didn’t work, the most likely reasons are tolerance from a recent trip (including LSD), a dose that was smaller than you thought, an antidepressant such as an SSRI, or mushrooms that lost potency in storage. Your mindset and setting also shape how strongly psilocybin is felt, so a quiet first hour is not always a failed trip.
The fix is almost never to take more on the same day. Wait, work out which cause fits, and plan the next attempt with a weighed dose, a known strain and a calm setting. Below is each cause, how to tell if it was yours, and what to change next time.
TLDR
Most “shrooms didn’t work” stories come down to five things: tolerance, dose, medication, potency and expectations. Tolerance builds fast: with LSD, the effects almost disappear after about four days in a row and start to return within a week of stopping (MIND Foundation), and LSD and psilocybin share tolerance (Isbell et al., 1961). In a Johns Hopkins survey, about half of people on an SSRI or SNRI felt weaker effects than expected, and the dampening could last up to 3 months after stopping the antidepressant (Gukasyan et al., 2023).
Never take a second dose to make up for a quiet first one, and never mix mushrooms with lithium, which was linked to seizures in 47 percent of 62 reports in one analysis (Nayak et al., 2021). Wait at least a week, weigh your next dose in grams of dried mushroom, and use our dosing guide to pick the right level.
Who this article is for
- People who took magic mushrooms and felt little or nothing
- Anyone who tripped recently and wants to know why the next dose felt weaker
- People on antidepressants or other medication who want to understand the interactions before trying again
- Anyone planning a second attempt who wants to get the dose and setting right
Lily Pelenis
Author’s note
“I took them and nothing happened” is one of the questions we hear from customers, and it usually comes with a worry underneath it: that the mushrooms were fake, or that something is wrong with the person. Usually the answer is more ordinary than that. A recent trip, a medication, a dose that was guessed rather than weighed, or a bag that sat in a warm, bright kitchen for months will all do it.
I wrote this to give you a calm checklist instead of a guess, and to steer you away from the one move that turns a quiet trip into a bad one: taking more on the spot. Everything below about tolerance and medication is linked to the research it comes from, so you can read it for yourself.
Why didn’t my shrooms work?
Shrooms usually don’t work because of one of seven causes, and most of them can be ruled in or out in a few minutes. Use this table as a checklist, then read the section that matches.
| Cause | How to tell | What to do next time |
|---|---|---|
| Tolerance | You took mushrooms or LSD in the past week or two | Wait at least a week, ideally two, before a full dose |
| Antidepressants | You take, or recently stopped, an SSRI or SNRI | Talk to your prescriber; never stop medication to trip |
| Other medication | Lithium, an MAOI, an antipsychotic or a tricyclic | Do not combine; some combinations are dangerous |
| Dose too low | You guessed the amount or ate under 1 g | Weigh it on a scale that reads 0.01 g |
| Lost potency | Old, ground, damp or stored in light and heat | Buy fresh, store whole, dry and dark |
| Impatience | You expected to feel it within minutes | Give it the full onset window before judging |
| Expectations and setting | Distracted, tense or expecting fireworks | Plan a calm, safe setting with a sober sitter |

Can tolerance stop shrooms from working?
Yes. Tolerance is the usual reason a second trip feels weak, and it builds after a single session. DoubleBlind reports that taking mushrooms again right after a trip simply does not work, and that after more than four days of repeated use it becomes extremely difficult to feel any effect (DoubleBlind).
How fast tolerance builds and fades
Psilocybin tolerance has not been studied much in people, so most of what we know comes from LSD, which works on the same serotonin 2A receptors. With LSD, the first signs of tolerance appear on the second day, the experience almost completely fades when full doses are taken about four days in a row, and the original intensity can return within less than a week of stopping (MIND Foundation). The classic human study found that psilocybin also produces tolerance, though less than LSD does (Isbell et al., 1961).
Cross-tolerance with LSD
Tolerance carries across. People made tolerant to LSD were also tolerant to psilocybin, and the reverse (Isbell et al., 1961). If you took acid at a festival last weekend, a mushroom trip this weekend is likely to feel muted, and the same works the other way.
How long to wait
Because the research points to most tolerance fading within about a week, our advice is to leave at least a week between full doses, and two if you want the full effect back and some time to think about the last trip. If you microdose on a schedule, the days off are there partly for this reason.
Do antidepressants and other medications stop shrooms from working?
Some do, and some make the combination risky rather than weak. Antidepressants that act on serotonin are the best known cause of a muted trip, but the medications to worry about most are lithium and MAOIs. A 2024 systematic review found both weakened and strengthened effects depending on the drug, which is why mixing is never a guess worth making (Halman et al., 2024).
| Medication | What research found | What it means for you |
|---|---|---|
| SSRIs (for example sertraline, fluoxetine, escitalopram) | About 47 percent of reports described weaker than expected effects (Gukasyan et al., 2023) | A likely cause of a quiet trip |
| SNRIs (for example venlafaxine) | About 55 percent of reports described weaker effects (Gukasyan et al., 2023) | A likely cause of a quiet trip |
| Bupropion | About 29 percent of reports described weaker effects (Gukasyan et al., 2023) | Less dampening than SSRIs |
| Lithium | Seizures in 47 percent of 62 reports; 39 percent involved medical attention (Nayak et al., 2021) | Do not combine |
| MAOIs (for example phenelzine) | Phenelzine nearly abolished the effects of LSD; no controlled psilocybin studies exist (Halman et al., 2024) | Unpredictable; do not combine |
| Tricyclics | Increased the effects of LSD in one small study (Halman et al., 2024) | Effects may be stronger, not weaker |
| Antipsychotics (for example risperidone) | Risperidone weakened psilocybin’s effects in a dose dependent way (Halman et al., 2024) | A possible cause of a quiet trip |
SSRIs and SNRIs
In the Johns Hopkins survey of 611 reports of mushrooms taken with an antidepressant, people on SSRIs and SNRIs were the most likely to describe weaker effects than they expected (Gukasyan et al., 2023). In a lab study with pure psilocybin, escitalopram did not change the positive mood or mind altering effects but did reduce anxiety and ego disintegration (Halman et al., 2024). So the dampening is real for many people, but not universal.
The effect can last after you stop
The same survey found that the chance of reduced effects stayed about the same from the first week after stopping an SSRI or SNRI up to 3 to 6 months later, and the authors concluded the dampening may last as long as 3 months (Gukasyan et al., 2023). If you stopped an antidepressant recently, that alone may explain a quiet trip.
Do not stop or skip an antidepressant to get a stronger trip. The NHS advises never stopping an antidepressant suddenly or without talking to your doctor first, because withdrawal can bring dizziness, low mood, anxiety and other symptoms (NHS).
Lithium and MAOIs
These are the two combinations to avoid completely. In an analysis of online reports, nearly half of the people who combined a classic psychedelic with lithium described a seizure, and the authors concluded psychedelic use may pose a significant seizure risk for people on lithium (Nayak et al., 2021). With MAOIs, one study found phenelzine nearly abolished the effects of LSD, and there are no controlled human studies of MAOIs with psilocybin, so the combination is unpredictable (Halman et al., 2024). If you take either, mushrooms are not for you without medical advice.
Was your dose too low, or had your shrooms lost potency?
Very often, yes. Dose is the single strongest predictor of how intense a psilocybin experience is, stronger than personality, mood or setting (Studerus et al., 2012). A dose that was guessed, a bag of mostly stems or mushrooms that sat in the light for a year can all land you below the level where much happens.
Weigh it, do not guess
Doses are measured in grams of dried mushroom, and the gap between levels is small. On our dosing guide, anything from 0.25 to 1 g is the threshold, where colours and music feel a touch fuller but you stay fully functional. Many people who say “nothing happened” were somewhere in that range.
| Level | Dried mushroom | What people describe |
|---|---|---|
| Microdose | 0.1 to 0.25 g | Barely felt; sub-perceptual by design |
| Threshold | 0.25 to 1 g | Colours warmer, music fuller, fully functional |
| Light | 1 to 2 g | Mild visuals, bigger emotions, still in control |
| Moderate | 2 to 3.5 g | Vivid visuals, altered time, deep introspection |
| Strong | 3.5 to 5 g | Intense; experienced people only, sitter required |
| Heroic | 5 g and up | Ceremony; advanced only |
Use a scale that reads to 0.01 g. A kitchen scale that reads in whole grams shows 1 g for anything from about 0.5 to 1.4 g, which spans the gap between a threshold dose and a light one.
Potency varies between mushrooms and between strains
Health Canada notes that the strength of magic mushrooms can vary greatly, even between mushrooms from the same batch (Health Canada). In one lab study, caps held about 1.03 percent tryptamines by weight and stems about 0.52 percent, though individual mushrooms varied so much that the difference was not statistically significant (Gotvaldová et al., 2021). Strains differ too: on our scale Golden Teacher sits at 6 out of 10 and Albino Penis Envy at 9 out of 10, so the same weight can feel very different.
Storage and age
Psilocybin breaks down over time. In the same study, dried mushrooms kept in the dark at room temperature lost the least, while fresh mushrooms frozen at -80°C lost the most (Gotvaldová et al., 2021). Experts interviewed by DoubleBlind add that mushrooms kept in the dark stay potent longer and that powdered mushrooms degrade faster than whole ones (DoubleBlind). Keep them whole, dry, airtight and out of the light, and grind only what you are about to use.
Were they magic mushrooms at all?
Health Canada warns that more than 200 species exist and that people do sometimes eat poisonous mushrooms they mistook for magic mushrooms (Health Canada). Never eat wild mushrooms you cannot identify with certainty.

Does eating before shrooms stop them from working?
Probably not on its own. A full stomach is the most common thing people blame, but a 2025 systematic review of psilocybin pharmacokinetics found no food effects reported in the studies where fasting status was known (Otto et al., 2025). Food has simply not been tested well yet, so a heavy meal is unlikely to be the whole story behind a trip that never came.
Our dosing guide suggests a light meal 60 to 90 minutes before, so your stomach is settled but not empty or full.
Impatience is a bigger problem than food
Effects appear within 15 to 45 minutes and usually last four to six hours (Health Canada). Psilocybin has to be absorbed and converted into psilocin, its active form, before anything happens (Otto et al., 2025). If you were judging the trip at the 20 minute mark, you may have called it too early.
This is also where people get hurt: they take a second dose because the first one seems slow, and then both arrive together. Decide your dose before you start and do not add to it. If the day turns out quiet, let it be quiet and try again another time.
Can your mindset or setting make a trip feel like nothing?
Yes, to a degree. In pooled data from 23 studies with 261 healthy volunteers, dose mattered most, but non-drug factors such as personality, mood right before the dose and the setting also changed how people responded (Studerus et al., 2012). Tension, distraction and a busy room all pull attention away from what is happening.
Expectations work both ways
A McGill University study gave students a placebo in a party-like room and told them it resembled psilocybin. 61 percent reported some effect, and some showed changes as strong as those typically seen at moderate or high doses (Olson et al., 2020). Expectations can create effects, and they can also make real ones feel disappointing: if you were waiting for fractals and got a slower, quieter afternoon, it may have been a light trip rather than no trip.
What a good setting looks like
- A calm, familiar place where you will not be interrupted
- A sober person you trust nearby, especially for a first or bigger dose
- No work, driving or plans for the rest of the day
- Music you choose ahead of time, water within reach
Our guide to set and setting goes further, and our preparation checklist covers the days before.

What should you do after a trip that didn’t work?
Stop for the day, write down what happened, and plan the next attempt properly. A quiet trip costs you an afternoon; a stacked dose can cost you much more.
On the day
- Do not take more, and do not switch to another substance to make up for it
- Note the time you took the dose, how much, which strain and what you felt, even if it was subtle
- Write down any medication you take or stopped in the past few months
Before the next attempt
- Wait at least a week, ideally two, so tolerance is not a factor
- If you take any prescription medication, check the interactions above and speak to your prescriber; never stop a medication on your own
- Weigh your dose and choose a level from the dosing guide
- Use a strain you know the potency of, from a bag stored whole, dry and dark
- Plan the setting and a sitter, and give the onset its full window before you judge it
If something did come up, even quietly, our piece on psychedelic integration is a good place to make sense of it.
Try again, the right way
A trip that didn’t work is almost always explained by tolerance, medication, dose or potency, and every one of those can be fixed with patience and a scale. Read our dosing guide before you try again, and if you want a strain to learn your own dose on, Golden Teacher sits at 6 out of 10 on our potency scale, in the middle of the range.
FAQ
Why didn’t shrooms work the second day in a row?
Tolerance. With LSD, which acts on the same receptors, tolerance shows from the second day, and LSD and psilocybin share tolerance (MIND Foundation; Isbell et al., 1961). Wait at least a week before your next full dose.
Should I take more if I don’t feel anything after an hour?
No. Effects can take up to 45 minutes to appear and build after that (Health Canada), and a second dose can land on top of the first. Decide your dose before you start and stick to it.
Do SSRIs stop shrooms from working?
Often, but not always. About 47 percent of reports from people on SSRIs described weaker than expected effects, and the dampening may last up to 3 months after stopping (Gukasyan et al., 2023). Never stop an antidepressant without your doctor.
Can you be immune to magic mushrooms?
There is no evidence that anyone is fully immune. Dose is the strongest predictor of the effect (Studerus et al., 2012), so a weak response usually points to dose, tolerance, medication or potency.
Do old shrooms lose potency?
Yes. Psilocybin breaks down over time; dried mushrooms kept in the dark at room temperature lost the least in lab testing (Gotvaldová et al., 2021). Ground or damp mushrooms lose strength faster.
How long should I wait between mushroom trips?
We suggest at least a week, ideally two. LSD research suggests most tolerance fades within about a week, and the extra time lets you reflect on the last experience before the next one.
Why don’t I feel my microdose?
That is the point of it. A microdose is 0.1 to 0.25 g of dried mushroom and is meant to sit below the level you notice; see the dosing guide for the full range.
Find your strain, then your dose
Every product on the shelf shows its potency rating and the effects people report. The dosing guide walks through amounts before you order, and a real person answers if you write to us.
About the author
Lily Pelenis
I'm a Toronto-based lifestyle coach, psilocybin enthusiast and certified yoga instructor. I guide people toward mindful, balanced living, and my coaching blends modern wellness practices with ancient wisdom to help clients find deeper self-awareness, resilience and joy.
I've been experimenting with shrooms for over a decade, and I write about my own experience. I love nature, psychology and humans. That is why my articles tend to follow a trip past its peak and into the weeks after it.
Some pieces start with a strain I have tried myself, such as Golden Teacher or Albino Roller Coaster. Others are the practical ones, like how much to take the first time or how to brew a tea that sits easier on the stomach. Over the years I've learned that intention is everything, so I write about why you are taking it before I get to how.
50% off your first order
New strains, restocks, sales and new writing from the Notebook, by email. No spam, unsubscribe any time.









